LANGUAGE IN THE OPTICS OF WAR
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17721/folia.philologica/2024/8/4Keywords:
language, language militarisation, war, discourse, discursive determinism, worldview, narrative, military narrativeAbstract
Language security studies are currently undergoing a phase of intensive formation. Recent research explores language both as an object of study and as a subject of security and military studies. This article aims to provide a scholarly interpretation of language as an object of language security research. Language acquires military determinism alongside its status as a national value, which falls within the scope of national interest, particularly when such a status is discursively accentuated. In situations of threat or emerging danger, any language – especially when it serves as a crucial element of a society’s political framework, a marker of ethno-political identity, a symbol of its native speakers, and a matter of national interest – demonstrates its inherent militarisation. The exemplary material includes the existentially distinct Yugoslav military events between 1991 and 2001, as well as russia’s war against Ukraine since 2014, including its full-scale phase from 2022. At first glance, language and war may seem like entirely distant concepts, yet they are interconnected through human agency. Language is an inherent characteristic of human nature, while war is a human conscious activity that cannot exist without language. The relationship between language and war extends beyond the individual to the state, particularly in modern times, where political language identity of it is almost always subject to protection, including military defence. Even if, for a certain period, language and war appear to occupy opposite extremes on the spectrum of human existence, there inevitably comes a moment when they converge, and language, despite all else, becomes an integral part of war. The militarisation of language typically manifests through two main models: 1) when, during a certain period, a shared language serves as a security instrument for many but, with a shift in context, transforms into a threat and disintegrates; and 2) when two languages exist in existential opposition, meaning that their organic coexistence within the same linguistic group, at the same time, in the same territory, and with the same functions, becomes virtually impossible. The Ukrainian language, which actualizes the second model, demonstrates its militarised nature particularly under the following conditions: war and occupation of part of its territory; the legacy of colonisation and russification; and external influences on linguistic minority groups in Ukraine.
References
Benedykt, A. (2001). Uiavleni spilnoty. Mirkuvannia shchodo pokhodzhennia i poshyrennia natsionalizmu [Imagined Communities. Thoughts on the Origin and Spread of Nationalism]. Kyiv : Krytyka [in Ukrainian].
Biriukova, O.O. (2010). Movnyi chynnyk u natsionalnykh vidnosynakh na rubezhakh zakhidnykh Balkan (krain kolyshnoi Yuhoslavii) [The Language Factor in National Relations on the Borders of the Western Balkans (Countries of the Former Yugoslavia)]. Visnyk Kharkivskoho Natsionalnoho universytetu imeni V. N. Kazarina. Seriia: Pytannia politolohii – Bulletin of Kharkiv National University named after V. N. Kazarina. Series: Questions of Political Science, 17, 240–251 [in Ukrainian].
Heneralnyi rehionalno anotovanyi korpus ukrainskoi movy (HRAK) [General Regionally Annotated Corpus of the Ukrainian Language]. (2017-2024). M. Shvedova, R. fon Valdenfels, S. Yaryhin, A. Rysin, V. Starko, T. Nikolaienko ta in. Kyiv, Lviv, Yena: Concordance | Sketch Engine. Retrieved from: https://uacorpus.org [in Ukrainian].
Hobbs, T. (2000). Leviafan [Leviathan]. Kyiv : Dukh i Litera [in Ukrainian].
Demska, O., & Cherniak, A. (2024). Mova. Pravo. Bezpeka [Language. Law. Security]. Kyiv : NA SB Ukrainy [in Ukrainian].
Ielavich, B. (2003). Istoriia Balkan XVIII i XIX stolittia [The History of the Balkans in the Eighteenth and Nineteenth Centuries]. Kyiv : Svenas [in Ukrainian].
Ishchenko, N., Popov, I., Ishchelin, P. ta in. (2020). Konflikty, shcho zminyly svit [Conflicts that Changed the World]. Kharkiv : Folio [in Ukrainian].
Kappeler, A. (2005). Rosiia yak polietnichna imperiia: Vynyknennia. Istoriia. Rozpad [Russia as a Multi-ethnic Empire: Emergence. History. Disintegration]. Lviv : Vydavnytstvo UKU [in Ukrainian].
Karikh, I.V. (2021). Aksiolohichna bezpeka Ukrainy yak kvintesentsiia natsionalnykh tsinnostei ta interesiv [Axiological Security of Ukraine as the Quintessence of National Values and Interests]. Natsionalna bezpeka: svitohliadni ta teoretyko-metodolohichni zasady: monohrafiia – National Security: Worldview, Theoretical and Methodological Foundations: a monograph. Kharkiv : Pravo, 374–394 [in Ukrainian].
Mova i viina: dynamika movnoi systemy i movna polityka: monohrafiia [Language and War: The Dynamics of the Language System and Language Policy: a monograph]. (2024). Kyiv : Vydavnychyi dim Dmytra Buraho [in Ukrainian].
Mortymer, I. (2018). Stolittia zmin. Yake stolittia bachylo naibilshe zmin i chomu tse vazhlyvo dlia nas [A Century of Change. What Century Saw the Most Changes and Why It is Important for Us]. Kharkiv : Vyd-vo «Ranok»: «Fabula» [in Ukrainian].
Parakhonskyi, B., Yavorska, H. (2019). Ontolohiia viiny i myru: bezpeka, stratehiia, smysl: monohrafiia [The Ontology of War and Peace: Security, Strategy, Meaning: a monograph]. Kyiv : NISD [in Ukrainian].
Plokhii, S. (2023). Rosiisko-Ukrainska viina. Povernennia istorii [The Russian-Ukrainian War. The Return of History]. Kharkiv : KSD [in Ukrainian].
Pocheptsov, H. (2016). Smysly i viiny. Ukraina i Rosiia v informatsiinii i smyslovii viini [Senses and Wars. Ukraine and Russia in the Information and Semantic War]. Kyiv : Vyd. dim “Kyjivo-Mohylianska akademiia” [in Ukrainian].
Pro zasady derzhavnoi movnoi polityky : Zakon Ukrainy vid 03.07.2012 № 5029-VI [On the Principles of the State Language Policy: Law of Ukraine of 03.07.2012 No. 5029-VI]. Retrieved from: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/5029-VI#Text [in Ukrainian].
Pro rishennia Rady natsionalnoi bezpeky i oborony Ukrainy vid 14.09.2020 “Pro Stratehiiu natsionalnoi bezpeky Ukrainy” [On the Decision of the National Security and Defence Council of Ukraine of 14.09.2020 “On the National Security Strategy of Ukraine”]. Retrieved from: ttps://www.president.gov.ua/documents/3922020-35037 [in Ukrainian].
Roshchina, O. (2024). WSJ pro myrni uhody: Vymohy Putina z 2022-ho ne zminylysia – khoche «kastrovanu» Ukrainu [WSJ on Peace Agreements: Putin’s Demands Haven't Changed since 2022 – He Wants a ‘Neutered’ Ukraine]. Ukrainska Pravda. Retrieved from: https://www.pravda.com.ua/news/2024/03/1/7444515 [in Ukrainian].
Riabchuk, M. (2024). Kartohrafuvannia «natsii nizvidky». Toksychnyi vplyv «imperskoho znannia» ta vyklyky dekolonizatsii [Mapping the «Nation from Nowhere». The Toxic Effects of «Imperial Knowledge» and the Challenges of Decolonisation]. Politychni doslidzhennia [Political Studies], 1(7), 86–109 [in Ukrainian].
Svitova hibrydna viina: ukrainskyi front: monohrafiia [World Hybrid War: the Ukrainian Front: a monograph]. (2017). Za zah. red. V. Horbulina. Kyiv : NISD [in Ukrainian].
Slovnyk ukrainskoi movy [Dictionary of the Ukrainian Language]. (2012). Kyiv : VTs “Prosvita” [in Ukrainian].
Slukhai, N.V. (2018). Linhvistychni markery svitohliadnoi masky subiekta masmediinoi interaktsii [Linguistic Markers of the Worldview Mask of the Subject of Media Interaction]. Stratehichni komunikatsii v umovakh hibrydnoi viiny: pohliad vid volontera do naukovtsia: monohrafiia – Strategic Ccommunications in Hybrid Warfare: a View from a Volunteer to a Scholar: a monograph. Kyiv : Natsionalna akademiia SB Ukrainy, 355–401 [in Ukrainian].
Snytko, O. (2024). “Bytva naratyviv” u mediaprostori Ukrainy voiennoi doby [“The Battle of Narratives” in the Wartime Media Space of Ukraine]. Stratehichni komunikatsii v umovakh hibrydnoi viiny: pohliad vid volontera do naukovtsia: monohrafiia – Strategic Ccommunications in Hybrid Warfare: a View from a Volunteer to a Scholar: a monograph. Kyiv : Natsionalna akademiia SB Ukrainy, 301–332 [in Ukrainian].
Sun-dzy (2023). Mystetstvo viiny [Art of War]. Lviv : Vydavnytstvo Staroho Leva [in Ukrainian].
Liddicoat, A.J. (2008). Language Planning and Questions of National Security: an Overview of Planning Approaches. Language Planning, 9 (2), 129–153.
Nedle, P.H. (1987). Language Сontact Means Language Conflict. Journal of Multilingual and Multicultural Development, 8(1-2), 33–42.
Serbian Academy of Arts and Sciences (SANU) Memorandum. (1986). Retrieved from: Wayback Machine (archive.org).